1947 Partition AND 1971 Liberation War = An Independent Bangladesh.
Mr. Md. Mostafa Kamal
Where did you find this :
"It is you who are so hurt person who cries or tears for division of so called Mother India."
Why are you attributing this on me?
Can you substantiate your false statement that I am espousing a "Mother India"?
After getting caught by lying about October-28 episode, you became so un-nerved
that you have brought that issue out of context .....
This is an age old tactics by the Pakistan lovers, Jamaatis also use this tactics in their
propaganda.
The article in your link is very ambigious. It is true that Suhrawardy and Sarat Bose [Brother of Subash Chandra Bose] jointly proposed the creation of United Bengal .The Hindu
Mohashova, a staunchly communal hindutva political party, counterpart of today's Jamaate
Islami tabled the main opposition to the concept of Independentt Bengal in 1971. Some
Hindu and Muslim leaders of Bengal supported Suhrawardy and Sarat Bose in their move.
Prominent among them were Kiran Shankar Roy (Leader of the Congress Parliamentary
Party in Bengal Assembly), Satya Ranjan Bakshi (Sarat Bose's Secretary), ABUL HASHIM (Secretary of the Bengal Provincial Muslim League), Fazlur Rahman (Revenue Minister of
the Province),MOHAMMAD ALI CHOWDHURY (Finance Minister in Suhrawardy's cabinet) and others. For a short duration, the proposal was discussed both at private and public
bodies and important negotiations took place among Bengal leaders. In fact, the concept of
a sovereign independent Bengal had its origins in the past. The adoption of the LAHORE
RESOLUTION in March 1940 was a significant step towards highlighting the demand for
Independent Bengal. .... these are all HISTORY....History can not be repaired but
falsification and twistings of history can be used to create new history ... that's what the
defeatist Pakistan lovers and their cronies are trying ...
FYI, there are no one shading of tears for the division of so called Mother India in our 21st
century world except for few Mohajir leaders (MQM) in Pakistan who diplore the miserable
plights of refugee Indian muslims in Pakistan & Bangladesh [see
]
Md. Mostafa Kamal's hypothesis of "Mother India" is a part of ISI's propaganda ploy to divert the attention of the masses from the real issues of Bangladesh which is: democracy &
people's power, eradiction of corruptions, fair trial of the accused, impending food crisis,
and punishment of all the collaborators of Pakistan etc.
Mr. Md Mostafa Kamal'as another contention:"If the East Pakistan was not born how could you get Bangladesh by severing India? " He should thank Mir Zafor and the
British occupation,because if Nawab Sirajudullah was not defeated and Clive didn't
win, there would not have been any Pakistan. Historically, Pakistan is a
consequence of British occupation of the Sub-continent.
I have no idea where this Md. Mostofa Kamal is comming from?
He is either ideologically motivated by the Pakistan doctrine or he is utterly, a confused guy.
His confused thinkings lead to his confused writing ... as always.
Last, but not the least, communalism in all it's form must be condenmed: be it Hindutva communalism
or be it Jamaati Fundamentalism and parochialism.....
Readers, if you are interested to read a comparatively unbiased paper on Suhrawardy-Sarat Bose
maneuvors for Independent Bengal please see (1) A move for United Independent Bengal/Harunor Rashid.
These are included in the book History of Bangladesh 1704-1971 (3 Vols-Set) edited by Sirajul Islam
and published by Asiatic Society of Bangladesh. Also read:
Amar Jibon - An autobiography by Dr. Badruddin Umar[Dr. Umar
son Mr. ABUL HASHIM (Secretary of the Bengal Provincial
Muslim League), of was an eye witness to the United Bengal move.
Thanks
Syed Aslam
PS: "In 28th Oct 2006 BAL's supporters plunged over Jamat's meeting leaded by Haji Selim & Dr. Iqbal" Lie! lie! lie! [Mr. Kamal is a true decendent of Goebbles? .... Ekta lie bar bar bolle ki se ta sotto hoye jai ... ?]
On 4/27/08, Salahuddin Ayubi <s_ayubi786@yahoo.com > wrote:
I am with you Mr. Kamal. Your rebuttal though is brief but it is exactly to the point. Looking forward to Mr. Aslams' answer.Salahuddin Ayubi
"Md. Mostafa Kamal" <mmk3k@yahoo.com > wrote:Mr. Aslam,It is you who are so hurt person who cries or tears for division of so called Mother India. Of course not me by the broken of Pakistan. Bangladesh is my only & last address in this world. Look at the Shekhor Commission's report on Indian Muslims. Comparing Bangladesh-Pakistan Vs India how many Doctors, Engineers, MBA etc Muslim scholars in those countries. If the East Pakistan was not born how could you get Bangladesh by severing India? It is the WB's Hindu leader who prefer to Join India rather than a United Bengal. Please see bellow;
Look your BAL's Netri Hasina was called the Chief Minister back in Kolkata. Was it lie? She laughed & never protested. So did you. So we want a PM of an Independent & Sovereign Bangladesh, which you & your BAL gong Kabir Chowdhury, Late-Wahidul Haq wants to go back before 1947 for United India or AKHONDO BHARAT MATA & say proudly JOY HIND.So it is the burning differnce between you & me.Thank You All,Md. Mostafa Kamal.
Syed Aslam <Syed.Aslam3@gmail.com > wrote:Mr. Md. Mostafa KamalThis is the reason that Mullahs abhor Free-Mixing ![Keep the women out of the University .... Co-education, Co-education .... NauzuBillah,NauzuBillah !!! - Sibir slogan]May be now she will quit BCL and join Sibir and turninto a Hijabi. Some people learn in the hard way andsome never learn...As far as I see, you are inherently a bitter person,you are angry and put all your anger on BAL becauseAwami League has broken your favorite Pakistan intotwo pieces. You seem to be quite facinated by theword BAL. It gives you and your buddies tremendousanount of complacence ....and inner satisfactions... Everything is yollow to the Jaundiced Eyesand everything is BAL to Md. Mostafa Kamal.Syed AslamPS: Your version of 28th Oct 2006 is out and out lie and total distortion of factsby Haji Selim & Dr. Iqbal. may be blamed for may other misdeeds, butthey didn't led October 28th episode. Even Jamaati Sangran didnt say so.Daily starNayaDiganto:NewAgeBd:None of these papers mention Haji Selim & Dr. Iqbal per se..Mr. Md. Mostafa Kamal, you have lost all his credibilities.. Lier, lier pants on fire !!!! You pretend that you have stoppedlying, but you have just gotten better at it ....- Show quoted text -
On 4/25/08, Md. Mostafa Kamal <mmk3k@yahoo.com > wrote:Mr. Aslam,Do you have really a sense of humour?In 28th Oct 2006 BAL's supporters plunged over Jamat's meeting leaded by Haji Selim & Dr. Iqbal. There were no gun shot from Jamat's end. What you're or your reference saying is totally lie. It was infact started by your BAL & not Jamat. If the Jamat's cader shooted 100 rounds of bullets so why there is no casualty by a single bullet shot? It is logical thousands of BAL supporters there & no one hurt by a bullet, how it is possible? As you see your BAL's student wing BCL's male persons brutually attacked on Shima Islam it certainly proves that you & your BAL are totally liars & have no shame. So please at least as you're quite better person than Eng. Shafiq, Arif, Abul then kindly show us sense of humour & abstain from these sort of Propagandas.Thank You All,Md. Mostafa Kamal.
Syed Aslam <Syed.Aslam3@gmail.com > wrote:Musings from a General
[ The source of the following writeup is an active-duty general in the Bangladesh Army. The author of this piece wishes to remain anonymous for obvious reasons. There are lots of interesting snippets here: a 2006 coup plan, Anwarul Iqbal's exist strategy to the UAE, etc. But I was not aware the Iazuddin has 20 pet dogs or that the government expenditure for those dogs is upsetting some young army officers, but the most important piece of information hinted in this piece explains why Moeen U. Ahmed's tenure as Chief of Staff was extended by one year. We were convinced that MUA will, after his retirement in June, step up to 'rescue' the country. But given the prices of essentials, specially the world-wide shortage of rice, becoming the de-jure ruler of Bangladesh is a no-win situation. So MUA, who is evidently a smart man (yes, I know the joke about Military Intelligence being an oxymoron, too) decided to extend his term by one year and remain the de-facto ruler until then. Does this mean the election will be pushed back until 2009? Generals are allowed to resign and enter politics, so we believe Gen. Ahmed is firmly straddling the fence at this point, but we will not be surprised if "unavoidable circumstances" pushes the election back. J @ ShadaKalo ]Who Was Behind the Military-backed Government in Bangladesh?[http://shadakalo.blogspot. ]com /2008/04/musings- from-general .html#links
Interesting stories started emanating from the Bangladesh military intelligence sources in Dhaka. The rumor states that Mr. Anwarul Iqbal, who was in-charge of Police Force was asked to withdraw police forces from the 'war zone' on October 28, 2006 where few political activists and demonstrators were beaten to death. A selected few media blamed the 'logi boita' for the deaths while the Awami League leaders claimed and a few private TV channels showed that the Jamat supporters opened fire while shouting 'morle shoheed, bacle gazi' (if you die, you would go to heaven and if you don't die, you become a winner for eternity). His Deputy Police Commissioners repeatedly apprised him of the consequences of withdrawing the police forces and argued that the function of the police force is to maintain law and order. He did not listen to their arguments. As a reward and for his obedience, he was picked up as an Honorable Advisor in the current military-backed emergency government of Dr. Fakhruddin Ahmed. Recently, he tried to put the Election Commission under fire by announcing that the Thana and local Parishad elections would be held prior to the national election for which the caretaker government was primarily installed. More interesting, as a precautionary measure, it is reported that Advisor Anwarul Iqbal has recently brought private flats in Dubai and UAE with a view to settle there after the change of the government. If the story is not true, he may submit a detail story on the 28th October incident as well as his income and wealth statement to dispel the rumors.
It is also reported that the British High Commissioner Mr. Anwar Chowdhury managed to diplomatically defeat the U. S. Ambassador Patricia Buetenis who desperately wanted to have the national election in January 2007. She miserably failed as the EU diplomats sided with Mr. Chowdhury and therefore, she was withdrawn within 15 months of her service in Bangladesh. Now she is posted as the Deputy U.S. Ambassador in Iraq. Reportedly, British High Commissioner Mr. Chowdhury was a trusted confidante of the Awami League President Sheikh Hasina and he continually briefed her to stand strong in her demands. At the same time, he advised the BNP-Jamat leadership especially Begum Khaleda Zia not to compromise. He really enjoyed the rivalry of the Begums, the London-based the Economist so aptly enumerated. He earned confidence of Sheikh Hasina as his father was an expatriate Awami League leader in the United Kingdom. He was also close to the inner circle of the BNP leadership especially Mr. Saifur Rahman by being a Sylheti, the most trusted Minister of Khaleda Zia. British Prime Minister Tony Blair appointed Mr. Chowdhury, a Bangladeshi native as the British High Commissioner to Bangladesh to get political support of the Bangladeshi British nationals. In spite of his efforts for another term, he has recently been withdrawn by Foreign Secretary Milliband. Unlike others he stayed there for four years. But the damages that he did to this nation's nascent democracy will remain afresh just like the British Raj's dual policy of divide and rule for years to come.
It is further reported that all arrangements were smartly made to have a military takeover in Bangladesh on October 28th. However Khaleda Zia's political advisor Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury, a shrewd politician that sided with Pakistan in 1971 Liberation War reportedly received information from Pakistan's ISI, the military intelligence forces and quickly foiled such attempt by hurriedly forming a Caretaker government headed by President Iazuddin Ahmed. Once the Caretaker Cabinet was formed, the military found difficulty to take over. President Iazuddin, a very selfish man has no love for the nation or nation's laws and rules other than himself.
When the advisors of the Caretaker government of Iazuddin Ahmed were making progress and getting positive response from the opposing political parties, Dr. Iazuddin Ahmed at the advice of few selected military and civil society leaders obstructed any resolution. It is reported that both the TIB and the CPD got reasonable funding to continue their criticism of political leaders to create public opinion against them without fully knowing that they became a part of the conspiracy. However, CPD's Chief was rewarded with an Ambassadorial post immediately after the installation of the military-backed government that received nearly Tk80 crore British fund.
As the economy is failing under the inept caretaker government composed of foreign trained international bureaucrats and there is no hope of recovery soon, the military is fed up with Dr. Fakhruddin Ahmed's government. Last January, four advisors were replaced and additional assistant advisors have recently been appointed to manage the economy. As it is not improving and there is not much hope of a quick fix, General Moeen U. Ahmed, the Army Chief is contemplating of handing over powers to an elected government. No wonder, while addressing the media this week he boldly stated that 'military has no political ambition'. Since last week a few generals have been quietly circulating the above 'untold stories' or 'classified information' as General Ahmed is convinced that leading such chaotic economy would be a bad choice now. However, before leaving the office, like a section of politicians that imported and enjoyed tax-free personal automobiles or made money out of such privilege, Army Chief General Moeen Ahmed rewarded him and his close associates with promotion and extension of service. That mentality of enjoying public benefits has not changed in spite of corruption jihad in the country. The current caretaker government will be over in 8/9 months, but upgrading of selected military ranks will continue even after its departure as the milestones of Fakhruddin government.
It is also reported that President Iazuddin Ahmed has been feeding his 20 pet dogs costing the public exchequer over couple of lac taka each month and as some young and dedicated army officers raised noise due to famine condition in the country, President Iazuddin to silence them extended the tenure of their boss, General Moeen U. Ahmed by a year. Question is; is it the same old 'give and take policy' of past governments in a new bottle? Or is it something new and fresh 'so-called reform' to deprive younger officers?
Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Yahoo! Mobile. Try it now.
Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Yahoo! Mobile. Try it now.
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
.
__,_._,___
